This morning I woke up to do some homework, turned on the television, started flipping and eventuall settled in on the Maury Show– the title of today’s show is “Busted…Married Men Paying For Sex!” If any of you are familiar with the way the show works, the title of the show usually only has implications for what one segment of the show is about. In today’s case, the title happened to relate to a man, apparently one who has been a regular guest on the Maury Show, who, as a hobby, follows men in his neighborhood around with a video camera in an attempt to capture them on film picking up prostitutes. The nickname he gives himself, “The Video Vigilante,” suggests that he thinks of his role in this scheme as ridding the streets of a crime which he deems unacceptable.
In accordance with these beliefs, the man goes about attempting to characterize the people that he catches in the act using outlandish stereotypes. Here’s his website:
http://johntv.com/
Combing the streets of Oklahoma City with his video camera, searching parks, streets, following men around from their homes, and women who hang around in parks, the Vigilante not only captures his “perpetrators” on film, he also attempts to approach them and have conversations with them. His idea of a conversation is accosting them for what they are doing, asking the “john” where their family is, and trying to get a shot of their wedding rings on camera. On his website, along with the videos that he posts, the Vigilante attempts to give characterizations of both the john and the prostitute. Often using characterizations of the prostitutes as being, “Dirty” “without dignity” “lewd” and “disgusting” and referring to them as “whores.” Furthermore, the johns are usually only accosted, both in the Vigilante’s posts as well as in the videos as simply being married and disgusting. Furthermore, he often tries to make note of the surroundings and where the people are engaging in these behaviors. Often he cites things like, “Notice the children walking by her,” or, “as she walks by this young, innocent man, he looks up at her. Obviously it’s because he knows she’s a hooker–” even though she’s fully covered by her clothing.
It seems as though its people like this man, the Vigilante, who give caricatured accounts of prostitutes are the ones who do them the most injustice. he attempts to give histories of these women as drug users and runaways, but yet doesn’t pity them or try to help them, he is more interested in getting them arrested…
In the readings by Chapkis, we discussed how sex workers often do the jobs they do by choice. However, it strikes me, both on account of the Vigilante, as well as through other media portrayals that that cannot be true across the board– there have to be at least a number of prostitutes who are forced into their work, in other ways than human trafficking schemes. However, even in these instances, what is it that makes prostitution being illegal a necessity to keep people safe? It seems to me now, especially in the light of this Vigilante and his characterizations of these sad women, that bringing prostitution out into the light might not affect how accepted the act is by guys like this, but at least it would be keeping these women safe and giving them more respect that guys like this are…